Skip to main content
10.19.2026College Men
Phil Tracey goes in for one of his three tries. Photo Roger Mazzarella.
Phil Tracey goes in for one of his three tries. Photo Roger Mazzarella.
Author: Alex Goff

The reduction of the size of the MAC may have helped the teams moving down to D2, but there is concern in the remaining four-team D1AA conference.

First off, Cincinnati had been touted by some coaches as an up-and-comer, but in the wake of the tragic death of one of their team leaders, the UC team has struggled mightily. They lost big in their opening conference matches and this past week lost via forfeit to Western Michigan.

That's a problem, especially in a four-team conference.

However, what this does is put control of their destiny in the hands of Western Michigan. The Broncos are 2-2, with two wins over Cincinnati and one loss each to Louisville and Bowling Green, both competitive. They could, conceivably, win their rematches to UofL and BGSU and finish 4-2 and perhaps even 1st. It won't be easy, but it's possible.

Meanwhile, just before Louisville took on Bowling Green in their second matchup in three weeks, Cardinals Director of Rugby Emil Walton announced to his team that he was stepping down. Did this announcement throw off the team? John-Henry Carstens, the 15s Head Coach, said no.

Carstens was still running the team and preparing them for the Bowling Green game.

Bowling Green defense vs Louisville. Photo Roger Mazzarella.

"We played a very good Bowling Green team that was prepared for us," Carstens told GRR. "We got a red card and after that pur discipline let us down. We didn't maintain our composure, and we allowed 19 points in the last 17 minutes."

Carstens is big on clarity of role for each player, but "we lost sight of what we wanted to do and it became a scramble. All credit to Bowling Green, they really did their homework."

Still, Gus Dwyer has been a strong leader for the Louisville and he will be key for them going forward.

Louisville scored moments into the match with an interception from Jack Eberle. Bowling Green got a penalty goal from Lucas Hickernell, but Louisville scored another try, this time from Rocco Balistereri. Prop and 2025 NCR D1AA Player of the Year Phil Tracey thundered through for a try to make it 14-10 for Louisville. 

But in the second half tries from hooker Gino Carlo and fullback Jake Capel, with Hickernell converting, put Bowling Green ahead 24-14.

Louisville got something back as Dwyer and fellow flanker Matt Krammer scored to tie the game 24-24.

But, with Louisville shorthanded, Bowling Green took control. Tracey scored twice more and flanker Colt Crabiel also went over. Hickernell converted two, and Bowling Green won 43-24.

So, what does this all mean? Assuming Bowling Green wins their two fixtured with Cincinnati and Louisville wins their remaining one match with UC, it all comes down to Bowling Green at WMU October 31 and Western Michigan at Louisville November 7. 

If two teams are tied with bonus points included, then the tiebreaker is points allowed. That's crucial, because Cincinnati forfeited on Saturday, and if they forfeit again, there's no major difference between points scored in a played game and points scored in a forfeit. That doesn't matter. What matters is points allowed.

Right now, Louisville, Bowling Green, and WMU are all in a virtual tie there, too. The team that finishes first in the standings gets a top seed in the NCR playoffs. The 2nd-place team probably gets an at-large. Third place? They could well be on the outside looking in.

Photo Galleries

Spotlight