Skip to main content
10.19.2025College Men
Iona vs Siena 2025

In a somewhat surprising result Iona logged their first conference victory of the season, holding off Siena 30-29 on Alumni Weekend at Iona.

The day was also the day for announcing inductions into the Iona Rugby Hall of Fame, and that was a big event in and of itself. However, Iona still came into the game underdogs.

Players such as Yacouba Traore and Ben Slade said that while Iona had been competitive in their games, they had also been undisciplined. Not only were they giving up avoidable penalties, but were also squandering scoring chances with a bit of white-line fever.

Well, they started the game with the same problem, and soon Siena was in scoring position. However, the Saints passed up chances to kick for goal and instead looked to go for points. There was a method to this, said Head Coach Jaco Woltjer—dominate set piece (which they were confident they could do), tie up the forwards in the middle, and then go wide.

Early-on, it didn't work. Iona was able to get out of trouble and then when the game morphed into a bit of a kicking battle, flyhalf James Phelps and his backs were able to counter nicely. That, in fact, was how Iona scored their first try, with Phelps getting them going and center Joe Leatulagi powering over. Phelps converted for a 7-0 lead.

Siena's power in the scrum was evident and Iona struggled to win some key attacking lineouts. And yet the Gaels were quick to get turnovers and in one such case were able to nab possession in Siena's 22 and set up for a charge over by prop Ronan Cahill. Phelps converted again and it was 14-0.

Siena responded with more pressure and looked to have strength in the scrum, but a weak side move for the Saints was stymied by Robbie Hopkins, who intercepted a short pass. Iona worked their way down to the Siena line, but when they got a penalty they rushed the quick tap and were held-up in-goal.

So it was Siena who scored next, using this big forwards such as locks Harvey Hogan and Anthony Guarino, along with No. 8 Lorenzo Sevilla. That set it up the way Woltjer wanted it. They spun it wide and wing Preston Frazier popped it back inside for center Luca Holloway.

Iona answered with a long run by wing Jack McRedmond and solid support. Siena infringed and Phelps put over a 35-meter kick.

Up 17-5 Iona was on the Siena line as the first half expired, but could not get the ball down.

Siena came into the second half determined to challenge the Iona defense more and they did. Some excellent running and wide passing saw Harry Ryder, Jon Hall, and Frazier find some space. Iona's cover defense scrambled well, but the tries came thanks to forward support.

Flanker Thomas Mann scored twice and scrumhalf Henry Thompson went over once to turn a 17-5 deficit into a 24-20 lead. Iona were not helped by an injury to flanker Bailey Worsley, who had been an effective runner and defender in the first half.

But overall it was a much more dynamic Siena team that started the second half.

Iona started to contain them as time went on. Phelps added a penalty goal. And then, with about 10 minutes (or so many thought) left, they got a penalty and opted for the lineout. A smart maul and then out wide quickly produced a second try for Leatulagi. Phelps, who was a perfect 6-for-6 on the day, slotted the extras and while Siena scored one more, it was out near the touchline and the conversion attempts drifted wide.

Siena had one more shot, but after they were driven into touch, the final whistle blew. Siena felt they should have had more time, but they didn't.

Dreams of making a run for the playoffs took a big hit for the Saints. For Iona, this was closer to the performance they felt they can give.

Iona Head Coach Kyle Granby said Phelps making all of his kicks helped but the team was also tactically smart in taking points when they were on offer.

"It's been an issue in terms of holding onto that discipline; we'll play a great set of three or four minutes of defense and then one little error makes it two or three minutes longer and exhausts us," said Granby. "The boys did much better this time around,. We're still not there yet, but we're getting there."

Photo Galleries