Skip to main content
11.20.2025College Men
Bowling Green and Virginia Tech played to a tight one last year. Photo Roger Mazzarrella.
Bowling Green and Virginia Tech played to a tight one last year. Photo Roger Mazzarrella.
Author: Alex Goff

Atlanta and Butler, Pa. play host to the D1AA quarterfinals and we still don't know who will move on.

Questions abound.

Two-time champs Kentucky didn't win their conference only to come storming through their play-in like they were world-beaters. But they face a Texas A&M team that isn't really well-known. New Head Coach Tui Osborne wanted his team to be strong on set piece and the breakdown, and by doing that they know they will be in any game.

Kentucky can run on you, and they have unleashed plenty of talent in the backs. But they will probably run into a physically bigger A&M side that will control the ball better. 

"We are not satisfied to just be in the game," said Kentucky Head Coach Sam Enari. "We still have room to grow and we know that Tui and Texas A&M are going to be prepared. While scoring that many points is great [Kentucky beat UNC Charlotte 79-0], we are more pleased with our defensive effort. Charlotte was fast and athletic and we were able to stifle their power rnners."

Osborne and Enari speak often and talk about coaching, sharing ideas and advising each other.

Now they are facing off against each other.

Also in Atlanta Tennessee will take on Sam Houston State. SHSU's game against Oregon State was perhaps closer than expected (22-20) but all that ended up showing was how tenacious the BearKats can be. They didn't panic. They didn't fold. 

Tennessee, meanwhile, is rested, peaking, and very tough to beat. They have beaten Queens University's 2nd side, Ohio State, Georgia, South Carolina, Clemson, Alabama, LSU, and Kentucky. The Volunteers are tenacious on defense. They are physical. They unleash their skills. They are healthy.

Out in Pennsylvania, Bowling Green takes on Virginia Tech. BGSU seemed to be playing well, but not in a dominating fashion, until last week. Babson had an excellent season, beat Northeastern to make the Liberty Conference final, and then Bowling Green beat them by 52.

BGSU Head Coach Tony Mazzarella put the performance down to preparation. That, and getting their kicking accuracy down. When Bowling Green plays in the far end of the field, things are a lot better for them. Prop Vinnie Pfahl scored two tries, fullback Joey Apel kicked well for points and for territory, and they capped off more tries from short range.

But Virginia Tech doesn't care. Virginia Tech has a tradition of an attitude that they are always underdogs and will never let that both them. The Hokies are fit, physically tenacious, and play hard through to the end of the match. With that attitude, they demand of themselves good skills, and it works. 

Consider that the Hokies won NCR's D1AA in 2021, won it in 2022, lost in the semis to Louisville 29-22 in 2023, and lost by two to Bowling Green in the 2024 semis. That's pretty impressive.

In the other matchup Louisville faces Boston College. BC's offense is very good and fans are still reeling from their massive comeback turning a 31-19 deficit into a 64-31 victory. But Louisville has enormous pride in their defense. They held regular-season conference opponents to about 8 points a game, and while Cincinnati and Bowling Green combined for 46 against them in the conference playoffs, they, generally, play good defense.

That's the battle.

Overall this appears to be a wide open D1AA. Louisville and Tennessee might be favorites to make the championship game, but BC, VT, A&M, and Kentucky could all do something exciting, too.

Questions remain.

Photo Galleries

Spotlight