Skip to main content
09.12.2026
Navy vs Air Force 2026. Dannies Noonan-Sloan Photography.
Navy vs Air Force 2026. Dannies Noonan-Sloan Photography.
Author: Alex Goff

The 25th Anniversary of the 9-11 terrorist attacks marked an extra bit of meaning Friday evening ain Annapolis, Md., as the USA Naval Academy hosted the US Air Force Academy for the Shea Memorial Cup.

The challenge trophy between the two teams is named after Lt. Col., Kevin Shea, who attended the Air Force Academy but cross-commissioned into the US Marine Corps, and later taught at Navy. A punishing rugby player, Shea heled lead the Air Force to the 1989 USA Rugby National DI championship.

Shea served with distinction in Operation Desert Storm in the early 1990s, returned to serve as an instructor at the Naval Academy, and then was decorated for valor during the Global War on Terror in Iraq. On his 38th birthday, September 14, 2004, Lt. Col. Kevin Shea was killed in action in Iraq.

All of this was context to the game and what it means. The game itself was not really in doubt. Air Force, a club team playing its first match of the season with exactly one player who had played rugby in high school, was up against the 2025-26 D1A runners-up Navy, with a heavy senior contingent. Navy already had two games under their belts, and sported many experienced players.

Interestingly, the two captains had been rivals going back some years. Navy team captain Ed Soeder played for St. Ignatius HS in Cleveland, and Air Force captain (lilke Soeder, suiting up at lock), Will Grzelak, had played for St. Edward HS, also in Cleveland. Those two temas are bitter rivals.

Navy vs Air Force 2026. Dannies Noonan-Sloan Photography.
Air Force did have some promising moments on attack. Dannies Noonan-Sloan Photography.

Air Force showed what they wanted to accomplish early—play fast, utilize speed, and if there is no go-forward, kick for territory.

The kicks will come in time, but in this match they didn't garner enough distance to worry Navy all that much.

The first Air Force kick took a bit of a Navy bounce, and the Midshipment went wide before fullback Drew Baublitz sol a dummy and raced through for 70 meters. The Mids followed tha up with a well-executed lineout-and-maul to score their second. 

A turnover led to Navy spinning the ball wide quickly and Sean Donohue going over.

Dalton Sand capped off a maul for another, and then hooker Ian Bullock cut back against the grain and raced through for a very long gallop and a try that most hookers could not accomplish.

Repeat penalties saw Air Force take a yellow card, and Navy crashed it over. Kade Williams converted five of the second first-half tries, and Navy had a commanding 45-0 lead.

Navy went on to win 78-0. Air Force did slow down the onslaught for a time, and forced some turnovers with hard-hitting tackles. The Zoomies showed an ability to test the Navy defense, and if their lineout had come together a bit better, they might have scored.

Navy vs Air Force 2026. Dannies Noonan-Sloan Photography.
Navy's defense was consistent and solid. Dannies Noonan-Sloan Photography.

But, as noted above, where these teams are in how they are put together, supported, run, and how much they have played, all played a role.

Coming out of the game, Grzelak said the lessons his team learned, plus the fight they put in until the end, will stand them in good stead in the upcoming Rocky Mountain Conference season.

Head Coach John Cullen was philosophical about the game understanding this was a very tough game for a warmup match, but that Air Force put a lot into it, which is, perhaps, all you can ask.

For Navy, Soeder was characteristically classy in receiving the Shea Cup, thanking Air Force to making the trip and speaking about how much fun it is for his tea to play a fellow Service Academy. The teams assembled for a mixed teams photo.

Navy and Air Force at the 2026 Shea Cup match. Photo Alex Goff.

Air Force does have some talented players, and against some 0other opposition they will find the tries will come. Navy's overall defense, attention to detail, and ability to change their pattern of play from tight to open all are top-notch.

Baublitz is a terror in the backline. Soeader is just an example of a forward unit that works enormously hard. 

Going forward, the Navy players feel they can, and should, be better.

Asked what the ceiling for the team is, Soeder said, quickly, "we haven't reached it yet."

Photo Galleries

Spotlight