GRR on X  GRR on Facebook GRR in Instagram GRR Vimeo Library GRR on YouTube RuggaMatrix America Podcasts Support GRR on Patreon

Men D1A Rankings Week 15

irish rugby tours

Men D1A Rankings Week 15

Mount St. Mary's makes a move. Photo Calder Cahill/USA Rugby.

It's been a few weeks since we updated this ranking as the schedule slowed down around Thanksgiving.

However, we have had UCLA's very successful tour of England and Ireland, and the CRAA Fall Classic.

The Fall Classic bowl game results forced us into some key decisions. 

1. Should Life move to #1? The short answer is "yes." While Life did lose to Queens 29-26 on November 2, they also beat Navy 23-20 and Saint Mary's 24-22, that last result being this past weekend. That's a pretty good record. And given that Queens is an NCR D1 finalist, it's not like that result was a major slip for the Running Eagles. Queens also lost to Navy, so if you're looking at the totality of who has currently performed the best against the very top-ranked opponents, Life is 2-1 with a points for-and-against of 73-68; Queens was 1-1 48-65; Navy was 1-1 73-39; Saint Mary's 0-1 22-24. So, yes, it's very close near the top (Lindenwood is saying "ahem ... we exist!" 

2. Mount St. Mary's. How good are they? Well if you look at their record this fall, they won every game they should be expected to win, and all of the games that were kind of a pick-'em. Their only losses were to Life, Navy, and Queens. Their victory over Arizona (yes, an Arizona that isn't fully cooked yet) was impressive. So then we looked to see how far they should go. Our big question ended up being, does Mount St. Mary's deserve to be ranked above Army? Well, while they didn't play each other, they did share six common opponents. And they were very close. The winning or losing margins (only loss for each in that list was to Navy) were virtually the same in every game except one. Overall MSM was 5-1 with a points difference for +60 and Army was 5-1 with a PD of +90.

However, what put Mount St. Mary's over the top was the win over Arizona and the 21-19 loss to Life where they could easily have won. What's great about all of this is the Mount has Lindenwood on their schedule next year. So if we've got it wrong, we'll find out.

3. Air Force moves up in part because we hadn't really ever taken into account their win over Colorado, and then their win over SVU was a good result, too.

4. One final note. We had taken a bit of a risk, potentially, in having Arkansas State at #12 and Penn State at #13. Well, guess what? Arkansas State beat Penn State 38-32. Seems about right.

Rk. Prev. College Team Conference Notes
1 2 Life University Rugby East Beat Saint Mary's (3)
2 1 Navy Rugby East  
3 3 Saint Mary's California Close loss to Life (2)
4 4 Lindenwood Midwest  
5 5 BYU Rocky Mountain  
6 6 Cal PAC Beat CSULB
7 9 Mount St. Mary's Rugby East Beat Arizona (11)
8 7 Army Rugby East  
9 8 Central Washington Independent  
10 15 UCLA PAC Beat Bristol U., UC Dublin. Lost to Oxford U.
11 12 Arkansas State Midwest Beat Penn State (13)
12 13 Penn State Rugby East Close loss to Arkansas State (12)
13 11 Arizona PAC Lost to Mount St. Mary's (9)
14 10 Mary Washington Rugby East  
15 14 Adrian Midwest  
16 16 Davenport Midwest  
17 18 Colorado State Rocky Mountain  
18 22 Air Force Rocky Mountain Beat Southern Virginia
19 17 Ohio State Big 10 Lost to St. Thomas
20 20 Grand Canyon Independent  
21 21 Cal Poly California  
22 19 Colorado Rocky Mountain  
23 23 CSULB California Lost to Cal (6)
24 24 McKendree Midwest  
24 24 Illinois Big 10