Forty-six players have been named to the Heart of America All-Conference selections.
With the conference having expended, it was decided to make selections based on the two divisions, North and South. Each division had 23 players selected based on position. The entire Heart of America Conference has over 325 registered players competing.
| Heart of America All-Conference Selections | |||||
| North | South | ||||
| Position | Name | School | Position | Name | School |
| Prop | Seth Symond | Minnesota | Prop | Brooks Tate | Arkansas |
| Hooker | Luke Geister Jones | Minnesota | Hooker | Jackson Moulin | Arkansas |
| Prop | Alex Geisert | Iowa State | Prop | Spencer Glaeser | Kansas |
| Lock | Max Muhm | Iowa State | Lock | Jake Calbeck | Kansas State |
| Lock | Max Lofgren | Nebraska | Lock | Mike Callahan | Kansas |
| Back Row | Jared Johnson | Iowa State | Back Row | C.J. Corcoran | Mizzou |
| Back Row | Nathan Creech | Iowa | Back Row | Quentin Pithey | Kansas |
| Back Row | Tanner Tewes | Iowa | Back Row | Trevor Lister | Kansas |
| Scrumhalf | Sean Doyle | Minnesota | Scrumhalf | Quinn Tilley | Kansas State |
| Flyhalf | Russ Enea | Minnesota | Flyhalf | Aiden Olivier | Arkansas |
| Center | Nick Gill | Iowa State | Center | Nick Hafford | Kansas |
| Center | Josh Caldwell | Minnesota | Center | Jacob Reuter | Mizzou |
| Back 3 | Rowan Collins | Iowa State | Back 3 | Cael Kuhn | Kansas |
| Back 3 | Wes Cummings | Iowa State | Back 3 | Jackson Schemmel | Kansas |
| Back 3 | Hayden Friedrichsen | Iowa | Back 3 | Adam Strong | Kansas State |
| North Reserves | South Reserves | ||||
| Prop | Ben Withey | Minnesota | Prop | Isaac Mergner | Arkansas |
| Back Row | Nick Rasmussan | Iowa | Center | Gibbs Kell | Arkansas |
| Back 3 | Tyler Cahill | Iowa State | Back Row | Owen Schenk | Arkansas |
| Lock | Aiden Anderson | Minnesota | Scrumhalf | Luke Connor | Kansas |
| Hooker | John Ivan | Iowa State | Back 3 | Jonah Dalphino | Kansas |
| Back Row | Jack Robinson | Minnesota | Prop | Jack Bowersox | Kansas |
| Back Row | Sam Miller | Iowa State | Flyhalf | Braydon Leggett | Mizzou |
| Back Row | Nolan Sipe | Nebraska | Back Row | Remington Wilson | Mizzou |
