Skip to main content
11.15.2025College Men
BC in 2024. Photo @CoolRugbyPhotos.
BCMoves on after a stirring comeback. photo @CoolRugbyPhotos.

It was a wild and unexpected NCR D1AA playoff Saturday as Bowling Green, Boston College, and Sam Houston State booked their places in next week's quarterfinals.

Sunday will see Kentucky take on UNC Charlotte for the final spot.

The game of the day had to have been BC vs West Chester. Boston College's bus got lost (and, ironically, they were the local team) and the Eagles only had 20 minutes to warm up when they finally rolled in.

West Chester was waiting for them and unleashed a torrid first 30 minutes, powering through tackles and building a 31-5 lead.

Slowly, however, Boston College started to put themselves together. They shrugged off the initial setbacks, talked it over under the posts, and resolved to play with patience, understanding that there was still plenty of time left.

They scored two tries before halftime to make it 31-19, and then in the second half, built on that with a further 45 unanswered points. With their smart positional play and quick ball movement, BC was able to run the bigger West Chester forwards ragged. 

BC Head Coach Rob Conway was left shaking his head. 

"I have been in rugby 33 years and I have never seen a game like that," he told GRR. "To go down 31-5 and score 59 unanswered points, it just doesn't happen."

Conway conceded that his team suffered from the shortened warmup and were flat and lacked intensity in the opening quarter of the match. But what they didn't lack was confidence. 

"Even hearing them talk under the posts, they didn't get down," he said. "They had spent most of the first 20 minutes defending but they still were acting as if they could still win it."

BC was playing without their regular tighthead prop and captain, Sean Murphy, who is a massive leader for them. With Louis Freeman slotting into the prop role and with vice captain Picks Lively taking on the captain's responsibilities and forced to be more vocal, everyone was taken out of their comfort zone.

Add to that the injury to wing Patrick McMahon and the fact that many BC players had been ill this past week—scrumhalf Bobby Voth had come down with a 102 fever but some antibiotics and rest had him cleared to play—and you had a team up against it.

"This was an all 23 effort," said Conway. "But they were so calm about it. Those two tries late in the first half were big, and I think they just came out in the second half knowing they could come back."

It was an astonishing turn over events, and BC won 64-31 after being down 31-5. 

Boston College will take on MAC champions Louisville next week.

Sam Houston
22
FINAL
11.15.25
OSU Beavers
20
WCU Rams
31
FINAL
11.15.25
BC Eagles
64
Babson
3
FINAL
11.15.25
BG Falcons
55

Bowling Green defeated Babson in emphatic fashion at Niagara University, taking their play-in 55-3.

It was the end of the road for a Babson side that had jumped up from D3 and showed very well. But this was one week too far.

Bowling Green took control of the game immediately. 

Prop Vinnie Pfahl powered over for the first two tries of the game, and then scrumhalf Griffin Wilson and No. 8 Evan Holderer added tries, with Joey Apel converting all four.

Up 28-0 Bowling Green was on the front foot, but had to be sure.

Babson finally got some points off a penalty goal. Apel added one of his own. And then the Falcons rolled in the second half.

After halftime wing Gianpaolo Sferrella found some space and raced in from inside his own half.

Prop Kosta Anderson burrowed over for a short yardage try. Holderer stole a lineout ball and scored. Flanker Colt Crabiel ran one it, and Apel kept kicking.

It was an impressive showing for a Bowling Green team stung by a loss in the MAC final. The Falcons will taken on MARC #1 Virginia Tech next week.

And finally Oregon State met Sam Houston State in Denver and the Beavers gave a good accounting of themselves, pushing the heavily favored Bearkats to a two-point game.

Sam Houston pulled it out 22-20 but it was tough going.

Oregon State showcased some slick ball-handling and some pace, burning SHSU on the outside a few times to lead 17-8 at halftime.

"We're a pretty good team when we avoid penalties, but when we let our discipline slip we get into trouble," said SHSU Head Coach Luke Nenes. "At halftime the guys knew what we had to do."

OSU also defended the Sam Houston lineout well and disrupted the BearKats' possession. So the second half was centered around avoiding penalties, winning better ball, and defending on the edge.

It began to come together. Hooker Drake Torno was huge again for Sam Houston, scoring two tries, while flanker Malachi Pacheco roamed the field untiring, making tackles, working in the breakdown, and generally doing the stuff that doesn't get the glory.

Flyhalf Devon Smith and fullback Tate Standridge started to put smart kicks back into Beaver territory. The result was two converted tries to one unconverted by Oregon State, and a 22-20 win for Sam Houston.

The BearKats now look to next week and Tennessee.

"They are a very tough team," said Nenes. "They are #1 for a reason. But I feel we have the talent to compete with anybody."

Photo Galleries